as some of you know, i have been a little bit obsessed with this film for the last month or so. according to IMDB, Winter's Bone is about "an unflinching Ozark Mountain girl who hacks through dangerous social terrain as she hunts down her drug-dealing father while trying to keep her family intact." well, i finally got to see it tonight and it was brilliant (in an exceptionally dark way).
of course i loved dark subject matter & the stark cinematography. filmed on location in rural Missouri, the film did a good job of capturing rural southern poverty. a few silly film reviewers (who always disagree with the consensus to get attention) complained that it was a caricature of these lives. clearly these reviewers have never ventured out to the farms of rural Tennessee. it was pretty accurate. and even though i grew up in a subdivision in "the city", in some ways, these people remind me of home. also, thanks to being a missionary, i am rather familiar with/fascinated by the meth culture. combine southern poverty and meth? i'm already in love.
i also enjoyed the restraint shown with the subject matter and the violence. even though it was realistic about the desperation of this town, it did not needlessly dwell on the horror of their lives. the violence that occurs happens off-screen. i really appreciate it when directors let us surmise without throwing violence or sex in our faces. i don't need to see someone getting beaten up to know it happened. (it was rated R for a few f-words & people doing meth on screen. nothing we haven't all seen in real life, right?... ok, and for the violence that happens just out of the frame)
finally, i liked that the female characters really drove the story. (the film was directed by a woman, but based on a book by a man, which makes the feminist overtones even better). because, lets be honest, in that culture, women do drive much of what happens. as RationalThought said, "the men are too busy cooking meth". obviously the main character is the heroine, but with the exception of her uncle, all the major actions are performed by the women in her community. the film did a good job of displaying the paternal culture and how women both manipulate it and are manipulated by it.
things i did not love: the black & white dream sequence (unnecessary) & the weird close-ups of that horse on the porch (too jarring/what was the point?). also, how did Ree turn out so put together in that mess of a family? this is not explained.
final thought: even though i liked the film for the souther meth edge, this same plot line could take place in Arizona on the rez or in western Atlanta (with crack replacing meth). really, anywhere poverty & drugs mix (and there is rarely one without the other), people have these lives.
overall, Winter's Bone was excellent. i give it 5 out of 5 stars.
No comments:
Post a Comment